Dialogue
vs. Conversation
Do you know the difference?
Have you ever had a critique partner tell you that the communication between
your characters is conversation?
Nobody wants to read conversation. Conversation between the pages of a
book is boring. Conversation is what happens in real life and while it works
perfectly well there, it doesn’t when translated to story form.
According to Thesaurus.com, this is the difference between dialogue and conversation
Synonyms for Dialogue
Talk, chat, colloquy, communication, confab, confabulation, conference,
conversation, converse, dialog, discourse, discussion, duologue, exchange,
flap, interlocution, lines, parlance, parley, powwow, rap, rap session,
remarks, repartee, script, sides, small talk.
Synonyms for Conversation
Dialogue, discourse, chat, colloquy, comment, communication, communion,
confab, confabulation, conference, consultation, converse, debate, discussion,
exchange, expression, gab, gossip, hearing, intercourse, jive, observation,
palaver, parley, pillow talk, powwow, questioning, remark, repartee, speech,
talk, talkfest, tète-à-tète, ventilation, visit, yak.
On the surface, not a lot of difference. So why am I saying there is?
Because we are speaking in terms of creative writing and when we create a
story, we want it to SOUND like real life, but if we imitate the way people
speak for real, we’ll end up with dialogue which is hard to read.
Listen to people having a conversation. I’m sure you’ll notice how they barge
into each other’s points, cut across, leave thoughts half said and ramble all
over the place. And don’t forget all the what’s its, thingies, and thingamajigs
we use to substitute for things we forget the name of.
Don’t get me wrong, using a smattering of this can add depth to a novel,
but too much will kill it.
So we’re talking about dialogue vs. conversation. Although the synonyms
for both are pretty much the same. The difference is this: Dialogue does a job.
It must provide the reader with information that advances the plot, foreshadow
a coming event, add subtext, and show characterization, which makes the reader
believe these people could be living right next door to her. It should be crisp
and unique to each character.
This is a scene between one of my heroines and a housekeeper, taken from
Ty’s Plaything, a full-length romantic comedy/suspense I’m currently working
on.
Mia
kept her attention on her bowl of fruit. She speared a cube of melon. “What did
you say?”
“I
told him I don’t know. It ain’t none of my business. Mr Manning pays me to look
after his house and his guests—nothin’ else.”
I think you can notice a difference between these two characters, even
with so few words spoken.
Conversation is idle chitchat—padding—and if it doesn’t do a job ie make
a point, it needs to be removed. For instance, having two of your characters in
a coffee shop chatting about the purple-haired woman three tables away is idle,
gossipy chat if your only goal is to have your characters yak about something
for a bit before you get into why they’re really meeting at the coffee shop.
However, if the purple-haired woman is concealing a gun, that’s a completely
different deal. Now we have a purpose—besides her shocking hair!—for the
characters to notice the woman. I imagine the conversation would switch from why would anyone want to be seen in public looking like that, to why would she be carrying a gun?
Just like how you wouldn’t let your character chat about the weather for
no reason at all, don’t let them chat about anything
for no reason!
Do you see what I mean? Make your dialogue worth reading. Be firm with
it, give it a job and make it deliver.
Dialogue should sound natural. The reader shouldn’t notice you giving
information a mile off. Obvious dialogue for the purpose of imparting information
is distracting.
Example: “Hey, Rita, remember that
time you broke your leg and had to spend all those weeks walking around on
crutches?”
“Yeah, I remember. It
still plays up when the weather changes.”
Can you say yaaaawwnnnnnnn? This is idle conversation and obvious information.
DON’T DO THIS!
If we were writing a disaster weather story, this info would be important—a way of foreshadowing—but even so we'd need to deliver it with a touch more skill.
You want your reader to sink into your book and lose herself between its
pages, so write dialogue that sounds like conversation, but isn’t idle chitchat.
Like scenes, let your characters’ dialogue do double duty.
To summarize: dialogue serves a purpose while conversation is idle chitchat,
and dialogue without a purpose is conversation.
Hope this clarifies the difference. See you at the next Pull Up A Chair
With Mon post. Until then, happy writing!
